?

Log in

 
 
10 May 2009 @ 01:54 pm
Challenge Thirteen Results  
Unfortunately we have to say goodbye to the following participant...

& by americangirl69
-8/00 & -5/+1

Sorry to see you go but thank you for taking part! Making the final four is awesome. :)

People's Choice:
by supportmybones
00/+6

Mod's Choice:
by sterre
I love this! The cap and cropping is perfect, and I love the prominent text.

Tally:
1: -8
2: -1
3: +6
4: -1+1 = 0
5: +1
6: -4+2 = -2
7: -5+1 = -4
8: -3

Thank you to the people who took the time to vote.

Direct Link to Voting

Positive Comments
[Please Note: Not all positive votes provided a comment so the number of comments here does not equal the number of positive votes.]
Fave: 3. It's a bit oversharpened, but the colour is great and I love the text.
3-great crop, coloring and text placement as well as font choices. overall lovely icon.
3: Great coloring, cropping, and use of text.
3: love the coloring and text chosen.
fav: 3 wonderful coloring, cropping, use of negative space, and text.
Favourite -4 great cropping and zoom and writing.
#6) this is such an interesting crop and use of text!
7 - Beatiful coloring and creative text placement

Negative Comments
Leave a comment with your icon number to get your feedback. All comments are screened but you'll be able to see them if you receive email notifications. If you don't receive notifications then leave your email address and I'll send your comments via email.

So, our final three is supportmybones stolenglimpse sterre. Congratulaions! :D The final challenge for you will be up tomorrow.
 
 
 
Heather: BTVS - Bangelamericangrl69 on May 10th, 2009 02:54 pm (UTC)
1 & 7 please.
stolenglimpsestolenglimpse on May 10th, 2009 10:56 pm (UTC)
2 and 8 please.
maddy: Buffy - Buffy/Angel - Is This Even Happesterre on May 11th, 2009 12:00 am (UTC)
Thank you thedreamygirl *hugs* I was worried that icon would get me eliminated, it's very different but I think it's great, lol.

Any comments for 4 & 6?