[lp] magic

Final Challenge (14) Voting

It's time for the final challenge voting! :D Well done to all our participants for making it this far. :) Good luck!

Voting Rules (different):
-You have to vote for your two favourite icons from each part

-No reasons are required. However, positive feedback is always welcomed. Constructive criticism is also allowed.
-Comments are screened
-The final three participants (i.e. supportmybones, cozycaffe & sterre) are not allowed to vote. - However, everyone else is allowed to vote, so get voting people! We need as many votes as we can so telling people about the voting is allowed and encouraged as long (as you don't try to influence anyone's vote).

Collapse )

[btvs] i only have eyes for you

Final Challenge Reminder

You all have until Tuesday 26th May (i.e. a week) to submit your icons.

The challenge post is here.


Extra Note about the challenge requirements, for Part Three:
[This is mainly for cozycaffe's benefit as sterre already knows and supportmybones your entry was fine] In part 3 where you have to make one icon that is a revision of your entry to a previous challenge, you must use the same screencap you used for your original entry, even if you're remaking an icon from a themed/pick your own cap challenge. - I hadn't been clear about that in the original post, but it's edited in now; I just wanted to make sure everyone knew.
[lp] magic

Challenge Fourteen - The Final!

We've reached the final challenge for Round Four! Congratulations to our final three for making it this far! :D

Collapse )

I hope all three parts of the challenge make sense but if you need any clarification just leave a comment and I'll get back to you ASAP! :D

You have two weeks to make your icons.
Deadline: Tuesday 26th May; 5pm GMT.

Good luck to all of you! :D

Entries: 01/03
[lp] magic

Challenge Thirteen Voting

Thank you to everyone for getting your entries in early! :D Onto the voting...

Voting Rules [Please Read all this information before voting!]:
Vote for the TWO (2) icons of the lowest quality, giving reasons.
Reasons should not be things like, "I don't like the font", "I don't like the colour yellow", "It's ugly", etc. Don't use words like 'bad' and 'weird'. Personal reasons are NOT allowed. If you provide reasons like this, i will ask you to change your vote (If you don't change your vote in time it will not be counted).
Please give me real reasons, like: the texture is overpowering, the icon is oversaturated, etc.
Also, please don't state 'It looks like nothing/hardly anything was done to the icon; please point out something that is actually on the icon itself. If you have trouble thinking of how to negatively critique an icon, perhaps instead of saying what's wrong with it, try to say what could be better, e.g. 'The icon would be improved with added contrast'.
Remember the point of the LIMS is to help iconmakers improve their icons, not for you to be mean.
Also you must vote for your ONE (1) favorite icon. A reason is not required here, but it's always nice to get positive feedback.

Do not vote for your own icons.
Post your vote as a comment to this post; all comments are screened.

Everyone is allowed to vote: if you are taking part you must vote!

Collapse )

Results will include an elimination, one people's choice and one mod's choice. As all icon makers have submitted two icons, results will be calculated the usual way for each icon, and then adding together the points each maker got. - I will hopefully post them on Friday, but I'll wait until we have enough votes.

PLEASE VOTE! This will decide our final three so please vote. The more votes we get, the fairer the result and it really helps eliminate ties.